Re-roofing Vs. Roof Restoration. What’s the difference between re-roofing and roof restoration?


Defining Re-roofing and Roof Restoration

For homeowners, the roof is an essential component of the house, providing protection against the elements. Over time, however, wear and tear or damage may lead to the necessity of either re-roofing or roof restoration.

  • Re-roofing: This is a process where the entire existing roofing system is removed and replaced with a brand-new one. It’s typically chosen when a roof has reached the end of its lifespan, or when repairs are too extensive to be feasible.
  • Roof Restoration: This process involves cleaning, repairing, and restoring the existing roof to its original condition. It’s a less intensive process compared to re-roofing and is often chosen when the overall structure is sound, but the surface has deteriorated due to factors like moss, lichen, or weathering.

Cost Implications of Both Processes The cost difference between re-roofing and roof restoration is significant, primarily due to the nature of the work involved.

  • Re-roofing: Based on the materials chosen and the size of the house, re-roofing can range from $100 to $150 per square metre, which would amount to around $14,000 to $21,000 for a standard Auckland home.
  • Roof Restoration: The costs associated with roof restoration are generally lower, with prices ranging from $60 to $100 per square metre. For a typical Auckland home, this would be between $8,400 to $14,000.

Environmental Considerations

Auckland’s residents are becoming increasingly environmentally conscious. When deciding between re-roofing or roof restoration, there are a few environmental considerations to keep in mind:

  • Waste Generation: Re-roofing can produce a significant amount of waste due to the removal of the entire old roofing structure. In contrast, roof restoration produces minimal waste, as only damaged parts are repaired or replaced.
  • Material Consumption: Since re-roofing requires entirely new materials, its material consumption is naturally higher. On the other hand, roof restoration utilises existing materials, hence is more resource-efficient.

Health and Safety in Auckland

Safety is paramount when it comes to roofing tasks. Auckland has specific health and safety guidelines for tasks involving heights:

  • Fall prevention measures must be in place.
  • Safety harnesses and other personal protective equipment should be used.
  • Workers should be trained in safe working practices for roofing tasks.

It’s also crucial to be aware of the weight being added to the roof during these processes, ensuring it doesn’t exceed the structural limit.

Council Requirements and Regional Specifics

Auckland Council has particular regulations concerning significant changes to properties. If you’re residing in East Auckland, North Shore, or Hobsonville, it’s crucial to check the regional council regulations:

  • East Auckland and North Shore: Permits may be required for extensive re-roofing projects. Always consult with the local council before commencing any large-scale roofing task.
  • Hobsonville: Certain heritage-listed homes might have restrictions regarding the type of materials used or the extent of changes permitted.

Making an Informed Choice

When deciding between re-roofing and roof restoration, homeowners should consider:

  • The current condition and age of the roof.
  • Budget constraints.
  • Long-term plans for the house.
  • Environmental impact.

Summary Table of Costs and Considerations

FactorRe-roofingRoof Restoration
Estimated Cost$14,000 to $21,000 for a standard Auckland home$8,400 to $14,000 for a standard Auckland home
DurationLonger due to the extensive nature of workShorter as it’s less intensive
Environmental ImpactHigher waste generation and material consumptionLower waste generation and more resource-efficient
Health & Safety ConcernsMore intensive work might lead to increased safety risksGenerally safer due to less extensive work required
SuitabilityBest for severely damaged or aged roofsSuitable for roofs that require surface-level repairs

In conclusion, while both re-roofing and roof restoration come with their sets of advantages, it’s imperative to assess the current condition of the roof, budget considerations, and future plans before making a choice. Whatever your decision, always ensure that work aligns with Auckland’s safety regulations and council guidelines.


Understanding Re-roofing Vs. Roof Restoration: Frequently Asked Questions

What is re-roofing? Re-roofing is the process where the entire existing roofing system is removed and replaced with a brand-new one.

How does roof restoration differ from re-roofing? Roof restoration involves cleaning, repairing, and restoring the existing roof to its original condition without replacing the entire structure.

When is re-roofing recommended over roof restoration? Re-roofing is typically recommended when a roof has reached the end of its lifespan, or when the damages are too extensive and repairs aren’t feasible.

What are the average costs for re-roofing in Auckland? Based on the materials and house size, re-roofing in Auckland can range from $14,000 to $21,000 for a standard home.

How much does roof restoration generally cost? Roof restoration prices in Auckland are generally between $8,400 to $14,000 for a typical home.

Which process is more environmentally friendly? Roof restoration is generally more environmentally friendly due to minimal waste production and reduced material consumption.

Are there any health and safety considerations I should be aware of? Yes, especially for tasks involving heights. Auckland mandates fall prevention measures, use of safety harnesses, and training for safe roofing practices.

Do I need council permissions for re-roofing or roof restoration? In areas like East Auckland, North Shore, and Hobsonville, permits might be necessary for extensive re-roofing projects. Always check with the local council.

How long does the re-roofing process take? The duration depends on the size of the house and the complexities involved but expect several days to a few weeks.

How long will a roof restoration project typically last? A roof restoration can take anywhere from a couple of days to a week, depending on the extent of repairs needed.

Which option is better for heritage-listed homes in Hobsonville? For heritage-listed homes in Hobsonville, there might be restrictions on re-roofing due to material constraints. Roof restoration might be a preferred option, but always check with local regulations.

Can I stay in my home during the re-roofing or restoration process? Yes, in most cases, homeowners can remain in their property during the process. However, be prepared for some noise and minor disruptions.

How do I decide between re-roofing and roof restoration? Consider the age and condition of your roof, your budget, long-term plans for the house, and the environmental implications of each option.

Do both processes come with warranties? Most professional services offer warranties for both re-roofing and roof restoration. However, the duration and terms may vary, so it’s essential to clarify with your chosen contractor.